Even though I wrote about the loss of perspective Wall Street had during this financial meltdown last week, I acknowledge that they were not the sole cause of our mess.
After reading Dan Wooldridge's "Begin with the Household" where he examines the meltdown at a more granular level I recalled my own experiences beyond Wall Street.
Dan cites Nouriel Roubini:
"So any unsustainable debt problem requires debt reduction. The lack of debt relief to the distressed households is the reason why this financial crisis is becoming more severe and the economic recession - with a sharp fall now in real consumption spending – now worsening."
Then I read The Wall Street Journal's "Bailing Out Ourselves: Bankers weren't the only ones who enjoyed the credit mania."
My memory took me back a little over two years ago when Christine and I were house hunting. Traveling up and down the peninsula (area between San Francisco and San Jose), we encountered several real estate agents, mortgage brokers, mortgage agents, and others related to residential real estate. By the time we moved into our new home, we met with a few real estate agents and mortgage agents who were pushing adjustable rate mortgages (ARM) and interest-only loans on to us.
"We have a great rate for a 5-year ARM. Actually we have this 3-year ARM and you can get more house for your money..."
The real estate agents didn't care if you to spent beyond your means since they make their commission and it was the same with the mortgage agents or brokers. It wasn't just the greed of Wall Street but the greed of Main Street. It was the greed of these key professionals in the residential real estate markets that helped create today's economic meltdown.
It was a blessing that my wife was financially very conservative and both of us are natural skeptics. Also my parents who were more conservative than Christine were insisted the we get a 30-year fixed loan for our new home. Everything turned out well for us, but many were victims (yes, victims) of some greedy real estate professionals.
Showing posts with label wall street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wall street. Show all posts
Friday, October 3, 2008
Friday, September 26, 2008
Wall Street Ignored the World of Uncertainty
(heads up since this post has religious references)
As our financial world has been in a tailspin, I’ve been reflecting on the numerous events and stories that have surrounded my life over the past few months, such as my younger brother’s experience at Bear Sterns, my cousin’s at Merrill Lynch and friends at other investment firms. I was also concerned whether we are in the eye before the hurricane or near the end of a terrible storm as Congress deliberates on Secretary Paulson’s plan. These thoughts brought me again to 1 Timothy 6:17-18:
“Command those who are rich in this present world not to be arrogant nor to put their hope in wealth, which is so uncertain, but to put their hope in God, who richly provides us with everything for our enjoyment. Command them to do good, to be rich in good deeds, and to be generous and willing to share.”
I hate using the same verse in my posts, however this verse from 1 Timothy was relevant again but in a different context. As I read it today, the part that stuck out for me was “nor to put their hope in wealth, which is so uncertain.” It seems some people on Wall Street became enamored by their salaries, SIVs (structured investment vehicle) that falsely created enormous revenues leading to those huge bonuses, and the certainty of their wealth. If wealth is certain anywhere, it would be on Wall Street. In Silicon Valley a decent startup exit would be a few million, but that is the annual salary of managing directors from a bulge-bracket investment bank. While the highs may be higher in Silicon Valley, wealth is built more consistently on Wall Street. Also there is a built-in humility for people in Silicon Valley because many entrepreneurs realize the value of luck in their process to hit a double or a home run. They see thirty file storage companies scrabbling to survive and hope their company will end up on top or within the top three, and then hope for an IPO or acquisition.
Maybe having a biblical perspective would have tapered Wall Street’s uncontrolled enthusiasm and behavior over the past several years? I’m not talking about going to church, but having a Biblical perspective that had a grounded worldview with a core principle that we live in an uncertain world. It’s a perspective that we are not in control and nothing is certain in this world. It’s interesting to note that I found the word “uncertain” in this form nowhere else in the Bible. Maybe God knows wealth is the thing that can distract people the most and create an air of misleading certainty.
Even if you hire the best quant jocks for your investment fund, with PhDs from MIT, and economic models built by University of Chicago professors, you still cannot predict the future of our markets. If you have a server farm of a thousand computers and engineering and math wizards from Caltech, what program could be created that would guarantee certainty in any financial system? Nothing is certain but God.
“Come now, you who say, ‘Today or tomorrow we will go to such and such a city, and spend a year there and engage in business and make a profit.’ Yet you do not know what your life will be like tomorrow. You are just a vapor that appears for a little while and then vanishes away. Instead, you ought to say, ‘If the Lord wills, we will live and also do this or that.’ But as it is, you boast in your arrogance; all such boasting is evil.” James 4:13-16
Uncertainty is not the worldview of Stephen Hawking, who is a determinist and believes everything is governed by cause and effect so human freedom is nonexistent. If Hawking was in finance, he might have collapsed our whole system years ago with an overconfidence in mathematical models and their powers of predictability. A better worldview is sometimes a seemingly illogical (or at least less logical) one. It’s a worldview that places God firmly in the center and accepts uncertainty as a pattern in life.
The danger in seeking a more biblical worldview is asking for God’s involvement in your life. Because God can certainly remind you of life’s uncertainty and inform you that he, not you, is the master of the universe. Just ask Moses or Job or David. From this worldview, humility drapes your being. Wealth is no longer certain. It is a gift, and others would call it luck or fortune. Exotic financial vehicles with minimum risk and infinite upside simply are not a reality in a God-centered world. The only gift of infinite upside is grace and your hedge is mercy.
Wall Street has had its head on collision with the world of uncertainty. Hopefully this will bring into light the only certainty in our world.
Originally posted at InsideWork (no longer an active site).
As our financial world has been in a tailspin, I’ve been reflecting on the numerous events and stories that have surrounded my life over the past few months, such as my younger brother’s experience at Bear Sterns, my cousin’s at Merrill Lynch and friends at other investment firms. I was also concerned whether we are in the eye before the hurricane or near the end of a terrible storm as Congress deliberates on Secretary Paulson’s plan. These thoughts brought me again to 1 Timothy 6:17-18:
“Command those who are rich in this present world not to be arrogant nor to put their hope in wealth, which is so uncertain, but to put their hope in God, who richly provides us with everything for our enjoyment. Command them to do good, to be rich in good deeds, and to be generous and willing to share.”
I hate using the same verse in my posts, however this verse from 1 Timothy was relevant again but in a different context. As I read it today, the part that stuck out for me was “nor to put their hope in wealth, which is so uncertain.” It seems some people on Wall Street became enamored by their salaries, SIVs (structured investment vehicle) that falsely created enormous revenues leading to those huge bonuses, and the certainty of their wealth. If wealth is certain anywhere, it would be on Wall Street. In Silicon Valley a decent startup exit would be a few million, but that is the annual salary of managing directors from a bulge-bracket investment bank. While the highs may be higher in Silicon Valley, wealth is built more consistently on Wall Street. Also there is a built-in humility for people in Silicon Valley because many entrepreneurs realize the value of luck in their process to hit a double or a home run. They see thirty file storage companies scrabbling to survive and hope their company will end up on top or within the top three, and then hope for an IPO or acquisition.
Maybe having a biblical perspective would have tapered Wall Street’s uncontrolled enthusiasm and behavior over the past several years? I’m not talking about going to church, but having a Biblical perspective that had a grounded worldview with a core principle that we live in an uncertain world. It’s a perspective that we are not in control and nothing is certain in this world. It’s interesting to note that I found the word “uncertain” in this form nowhere else in the Bible. Maybe God knows wealth is the thing that can distract people the most and create an air of misleading certainty.
Even if you hire the best quant jocks for your investment fund, with PhDs from MIT, and economic models built by University of Chicago professors, you still cannot predict the future of our markets. If you have a server farm of a thousand computers and engineering and math wizards from Caltech, what program could be created that would guarantee certainty in any financial system? Nothing is certain but God.
“Come now, you who say, ‘Today or tomorrow we will go to such and such a city, and spend a year there and engage in business and make a profit.’ Yet you do not know what your life will be like tomorrow. You are just a vapor that appears for a little while and then vanishes away. Instead, you ought to say, ‘If the Lord wills, we will live and also do this or that.’ But as it is, you boast in your arrogance; all such boasting is evil.” James 4:13-16
Uncertainty is not the worldview of Stephen Hawking, who is a determinist and believes everything is governed by cause and effect so human freedom is nonexistent. If Hawking was in finance, he might have collapsed our whole system years ago with an overconfidence in mathematical models and their powers of predictability. A better worldview is sometimes a seemingly illogical (or at least less logical) one. It’s a worldview that places God firmly in the center and accepts uncertainty as a pattern in life.
The danger in seeking a more biblical worldview is asking for God’s involvement in your life. Because God can certainly remind you of life’s uncertainty and inform you that he, not you, is the master of the universe. Just ask Moses or Job or David. From this worldview, humility drapes your being. Wealth is no longer certain. It is a gift, and others would call it luck or fortune. Exotic financial vehicles with minimum risk and infinite upside simply are not a reality in a God-centered world. The only gift of infinite upside is grace and your hedge is mercy.
Wall Street has had its head on collision with the world of uncertainty. Hopefully this will bring into light the only certainty in our world.
Originally posted at InsideWork (no longer an active site).
Sunday, September 14, 2008
Mad, Mad World! Wall Street Being Wiped Out
Today is buzzing about Wall Street and I've been talking with several of my friends about the mess that's happening in the financial sector. Lehman Brothers, the 158-year old firm, is expected to collapse. AIG is scrabbling now and Merrill Lynch just found a protective partner in Bank of America (expected sale is $50 billion).
This is also interesting since last November before I joined the Lunsford Group, my CEO told me that he believed at least a couple of the major financial institutions would collapse before the end of 2008. He said there were staggering problems that were still unaccounted for. He explained that there needed to be a restructuring of our overall financial system. Well, it's been more than a couple banks and my CEO called it.
My younger brother was at Bear Sterns and went through their collapse. It was the first tsunami that hit Wall Street this year, and luckily he got a position at an excellent M&A shop, Sagent Advisors, soon afterwards. Now I know a few friends going through a similar situation at Lehman, but the environment will be worse so I will pray for them.
Some more articles...
"Is the U.S. Going Broke?" Forbes
"Wall Street's troubles are yours, too" Fortune
"Cramer's 'Mad Money' Recap: Sept. 11"
"A Frantic Weekend That Wall Street Won’t Forget" NYTimes
This is also interesting since last November before I joined the Lunsford Group, my CEO told me that he believed at least a couple of the major financial institutions would collapse before the end of 2008. He said there were staggering problems that were still unaccounted for. He explained that there needed to be a restructuring of our overall financial system. Well, it's been more than a couple banks and my CEO called it.
My younger brother was at Bear Sterns and went through their collapse. It was the first tsunami that hit Wall Street this year, and luckily he got a position at an excellent M&A shop, Sagent Advisors, soon afterwards. Now I know a few friends going through a similar situation at Lehman, but the environment will be worse so I will pray for them.
Some more articles...
"Is the U.S. Going Broke?" Forbes
"Wall Street's troubles are yours, too" Fortune
"Cramer's 'Mad Money' Recap: Sept. 11"
"A Frantic Weekend That Wall Street Won’t Forget" NYTimes
Sunday, August 5, 2007
UNHAPPY MILLIONAIRES... HOW MUCH IS ENOUGH?
Buzz in the blogosphere yesterday was around this NYTimes article, "In Silicon Valley, Millionaires Who Don’t Feel Rich." This was a good read, but I thought it would have been a better and more amusing story if it was focused on Wall Street and NYC.
While the article described some disappointing people, there were those with a good perspective such as Celeste Baranski, former head of engineering at Handspring, and Bruce Karsh who stated in the article, "A lot of the money here is accidental money."
Randi Jayne, sister of Mark Zuckerberg, and other young startup employees or entrepreneurs should think deeply about Karsh's words. His statement reminded me of an old Red Herring article I read during the first boom times by a very successful entrepreneur. I forgot his name, but he co-founded 4 or 5 successful companies and had a couple failures. I believe his exits totaled a few hundred million and he created billions of dollars of value on the markets. After recently exiting his last successful company, in the article he still attributed his success to luck. From his perspective, there were a dozen reasons why his company should have failed and hundreds of reasons why his competitors should have succeeded, so his belief was that he was lucky or blessed or whatever you wanted to call it. I agree with his view on entrepreneurship and success because it's not just about how intelligent and hard-working you are. Most startups have at least 10 competitors working on a similar product, tackling the same problem to solve, and who have the same intensity. It's a race with numerous factors in the environment and landscape that can trip your team up or lead you astray, so humility is a good trait to acquire on the startup road.
I remember during my first startup back in 1999, my co-founder, Jimmy, and I met a wealthy entrepreneur who we weren't terribly impressed by. Jimmy turned to me and said, "Better to be lucky than smart." And this statement is something Jimmy applies to himself and others to this day.
Regarding Randi Jayne and other twenty-somethings like her, I write off their antics and views as immaturity. For others like Gary Kremen, mentioned in the article and founder of Match.com, I would just say, "Get over it, dude. Who cares?... Your not in high school any longer."
Why was he measuring his self-worth by money and material possessions? Why keep score? This is strikes me as insecure. Oddly insecure. For many of these types of personalities, there will never be enough. Much of their happiness or self-worth is centered around money and materialism, so it would be safe to say that I wouldn't want to work closely with such people. Money would be their primary driver for success or building a company, so these values would overlap into a negative, downward spiral at some point during a company's critical growth periods.
A few years ago I worked at a boutique investment bank and my colleague was complaining that because he was with our "startup" bank that he had to fly economy class. He was particularly irked that day because he just ran into some of his former associates that worked under him at his former employer, a bulge-bracket investment bank. The fact he was flying "a class lower" than his former associates bothered him greatly. I really couldn't grasp why such a silly thing would bother a person so much, but this was also a person that liked to keep score.
As I mentioned at the beginning of this post, this story would have been more amusing if it was in the hometown of the NYTimes but that angle has probably been overdone in their pages. In Silicon Valley, for every "unhappy millionaire" you get someone grounded and humble like Bruce Karsh or Celeste Baranski. In New York City (London and Hong Kong are interchangeable here), in the world of investment bankers, traders, and fund managers, it's a different animal. If you make it into the top tier of finance, the road to millions is more certain so there is less humility and a viewpoint of "accidental money." If you're on the banking side of a firm such as Goldman Sachs or Merrill Lynch, by the time you hit associate (4th - 6th year) level you can make $500,000 on a good year. This of course increases as you reach VP, Director and then Managing Director (titles vary for each firm). Anyway, my point is that there probably is a lot more wealth on average in the finance world than hi-tech with a lot more egos and a lot more oddities to write about.
What's also interesting is that in this world of more certain wealth, a question I receive more often from bankers and fund mangers is, "How much is enough for you to walk away?"
First, it seems to me that this question is a reflection of their industry and that many of them are doing it for the money. I'm sure there are many that are doing it for the love of the deal or investing (all of MY friends in finance:), but money is the sole driver for a good percentage. For me, money has been a motive to do a startup but a secondary driver. Even for my third startup, GoingOn Networks, whether it wildly succeeds or fails, I will do another because it's fun. I enjoy the process of company building from scratch to product launch and beyond. So I really couldn't answer this question because I wouldn't walk away. $30 million? $50 million $100 million? I'm not going to stop working at my age just because I can.
Second, the answer I often hear ranges from $5 million to $10 million. This was recently reiterated by a Silicon Valley billionaire I met a few months ago during breakfast. He said that he looked at this question a while ago and calculated that $5 million was enough to make him and his family be comfortable for life. $10 million was a point where he could make effective charitable donations to help others whether through his own foundation or other nonprofits. Or for other people anything above their life goal of hitting $5 million is keeping score. How much is enough for you? What drives you to work? What makes you happy?
Some other posts on this article:
Jason Kaneshiro, "Silicon Valley Is Messed Up: Single Digit Millionaires Feel Insecure"
Jeremy Toeman, "Those Poor, Poor Millionaires"
Anne Truitt Zelenka, "How to Feel Rich Even if You Think You’re Not"
Jeremiah Owyang, "Silicon Valley’s Middle Class"
Dave Winer, "The angst of Silicon Valley"
Winer's post is amusing because he actually separates himself from "Silicon Valley" since he's in Berkeley.
Buzz in the blogosphere yesterday was around this NYTimes article, "In Silicon Valley, Millionaires Who Don’t Feel Rich." This was a good read, but I thought it would have been a better and more amusing story if it was focused on Wall Street and NYC.
While the article described some disappointing people, there were those with a good perspective such as Celeste Baranski, former head of engineering at Handspring, and Bruce Karsh who stated in the article, "A lot of the money here is accidental money."
Randi Jayne, sister of Mark Zuckerberg, and other young startup employees or entrepreneurs should think deeply about Karsh's words. His statement reminded me of an old Red Herring article I read during the first boom times by a very successful entrepreneur. I forgot his name, but he co-founded 4 or 5 successful companies and had a couple failures. I believe his exits totaled a few hundred million and he created billions of dollars of value on the markets. After recently exiting his last successful company, in the article he still attributed his success to luck. From his perspective, there were a dozen reasons why his company should have failed and hundreds of reasons why his competitors should have succeeded, so his belief was that he was lucky or blessed or whatever you wanted to call it. I agree with his view on entrepreneurship and success because it's not just about how intelligent and hard-working you are. Most startups have at least 10 competitors working on a similar product, tackling the same problem to solve, and who have the same intensity. It's a race with numerous factors in the environment and landscape that can trip your team up or lead you astray, so humility is a good trait to acquire on the startup road.
I remember during my first startup back in 1999, my co-founder, Jimmy, and I met a wealthy entrepreneur who we weren't terribly impressed by. Jimmy turned to me and said, "Better to be lucky than smart." And this statement is something Jimmy applies to himself and others to this day.
Regarding Randi Jayne and other twenty-somethings like her, I write off their antics and views as immaturity. For others like Gary Kremen, mentioned in the article and founder of Match.com, I would just say, "Get over it, dude. Who cares?... Your not in high school any longer."
Why was he measuring his self-worth by money and material possessions? Why keep score? This is strikes me as insecure. Oddly insecure. For many of these types of personalities, there will never be enough. Much of their happiness or self-worth is centered around money and materialism, so it would be safe to say that I wouldn't want to work closely with such people. Money would be their primary driver for success or building a company, so these values would overlap into a negative, downward spiral at some point during a company's critical growth periods.
A few years ago I worked at a boutique investment bank and my colleague was complaining that because he was with our "startup" bank that he had to fly economy class. He was particularly irked that day because he just ran into some of his former associates that worked under him at his former employer, a bulge-bracket investment bank. The fact he was flying "a class lower" than his former associates bothered him greatly. I really couldn't grasp why such a silly thing would bother a person so much, but this was also a person that liked to keep score.
As I mentioned at the beginning of this post, this story would have been more amusing if it was in the hometown of the NYTimes but that angle has probably been overdone in their pages. In Silicon Valley, for every "unhappy millionaire" you get someone grounded and humble like Bruce Karsh or Celeste Baranski. In New York City (London and Hong Kong are interchangeable here), in the world of investment bankers, traders, and fund managers, it's a different animal. If you make it into the top tier of finance, the road to millions is more certain so there is less humility and a viewpoint of "accidental money." If you're on the banking side of a firm such as Goldman Sachs or Merrill Lynch, by the time you hit associate (4th - 6th year) level you can make $500,000 on a good year. This of course increases as you reach VP, Director and then Managing Director (titles vary for each firm). Anyway, my point is that there probably is a lot more wealth on average in the finance world than hi-tech with a lot more egos and a lot more oddities to write about.
What's also interesting is that in this world of more certain wealth, a question I receive more often from bankers and fund mangers is, "How much is enough for you to walk away?"
First, it seems to me that this question is a reflection of their industry and that many of them are doing it for the money. I'm sure there are many that are doing it for the love of the deal or investing (all of MY friends in finance:), but money is the sole driver for a good percentage. For me, money has been a motive to do a startup but a secondary driver. Even for my third startup, GoingOn Networks, whether it wildly succeeds or fails, I will do another because it's fun. I enjoy the process of company building from scratch to product launch and beyond. So I really couldn't answer this question because I wouldn't walk away. $30 million? $50 million $100 million? I'm not going to stop working at my age just because I can.
Second, the answer I often hear ranges from $5 million to $10 million. This was recently reiterated by a Silicon Valley billionaire I met a few months ago during breakfast. He said that he looked at this question a while ago and calculated that $5 million was enough to make him and his family be comfortable for life. $10 million was a point where he could make effective charitable donations to help others whether through his own foundation or other nonprofits. Or for other people anything above their life goal of hitting $5 million is keeping score. How much is enough for you? What drives you to work? What makes you happy?
Some other posts on this article:
Jason Kaneshiro, "Silicon Valley Is Messed Up: Single Digit Millionaires Feel Insecure"
Jeremy Toeman, "Those Poor, Poor Millionaires"
Anne Truitt Zelenka, "How to Feel Rich Even if You Think You’re Not"
Jeremiah Owyang, "Silicon Valley’s Middle Class"
Dave Winer, "The angst of Silicon Valley"
Winer's post is amusing because he actually separates himself from "Silicon Valley" since he's in Berkeley.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)